Like so many things for me, it all begins with music.
Back in 2017 I was still on Instagram. I am no longer a participant in any social media (unless you count LinkedIn...but should you?). Why? Well, that's for another newsletter. Suffice it to say that I discovered rather early on that the net effect of social media for me (and for everyone) is negative. But before that revelation, my favorite part of social media was discovery. At the time I was working on a software application for democratizing music discovery. As part of my research, I would spend hours on the internet trying to find new ways to find new music. One of those experiments (which in retrospect seems somewhat attenuated from music discovery) was to follow the social media pages of my favorite music artists and see who they recommended people listen to. I know this has already been solved for in innumerable playlists, podcasts and "curated" lists on pretty much every music platform. But, my theory went, there is a difference between (1) being asked to do something (or paid to do something) and then doing that thing as a performative action that is ultimately self-consciou, and (2) doing something spontaneously and out of the joy and inspiration of the moment. Social media, for all its flaws and perhaps because of those flaws, is a perfect way to see into the "id" of its users. So your favorite artist, who just got lit on a deep cut b-side of some obscure jazz record, will be more likely to give you a raw, emotional, authentic review of said record on their Twitter (ahem, X) feed the minute after they just got lit.
If you could still see my Instagram feed from 2017 you would find mostly my favorite musicians. The experiment sort of worked, in the sense that I think I discovered some new music. But ironically, and more relevantly for this newsletter, perhaps the most consequential thing that came from that experiment is the following post: